Sourcing plays a critical role in supply chain management (SCM), influencing costs, quality, material availability, scheduling, production, and ultimately impacting the efficiency in which businesses can provide products to customers. As businesses strive to optimize their supply chains, understanding best practices and navigating challenges in sourcing becomes essential, particularly as more businesses engage in sourcing globally. Let’s go over the basics and best practices of sourcing as part of the SCM process, and then we’ll discuss some related challenges and potential solutions.

What is sourcing as part of the SCM process?

In the traditional sense, sourcing is the process of identifying, evaluating, and engaging suppliers or vendors for all the goods and services necessary for the production process. In broad terms, sourcing (as an aspect of procurement) may encompass a range of activities, including everything involved in obtaining raw materials (where applicable), negotiation, legal compliance for any international sources, and supplier relationship management. Most business authorities, however, restrict sourcing to locating, negotiating, contracting, and collaborating with suppliers. Effective sourcing not only impacts operational efficiency but also affects customer satisfaction and profitability.

What are the primary benefits of effective sourcing?

1. Cost savings: One of the most obvious benefits of effective sourcing is cost savings relating to engaging suppliers who can provide materials, components, services, or products at lower costs than competitors, without sacrificing quality. If material/service costs are lower, companies can produce more per dollar and/or achieve greater profitability.
2. Improvement in quality: Competition among suppliers and careful selection of sources based on defined quality metrics helps ensure that services and materials meet or exceed required standards, leading to higher-quality products. Maintaining strong relationships with suppliers builds trust and encourages ongoing improvements in quality from suppliers.
3. Risk mitigation: Smarter sourcing specialists will contract with multiple suppliers, or at least primary and secondary sources. This reduces dependence upon any one source, and helps mitigate risks and financial damage resulting from supply chain disruptions. Maintaining excellent relationships with suppliers improves stability further, as a supplier who has a long working relationship with a business is more likely to go to bat for the company during times of turmoil, material shortages, political upheavals, weather events, or other disruptions.
4. Enhanced flexibility: Similarly to risk mitigation, a well-sourced, deep supply chain can more quickly adapt to rapid and unexpected changes in demand, fluctuating market conditions, or any disruptions. This helps ensure a steady supply of goods and/or services in any situation.
5. Shorter lead times: By partnering with reliable, trusted suppliers, companies can improve lead times and respond more rapidly to customers’ needs or other changes in the market environment. If it’s the fast that eat the slow, as Mr. Jennings famously stated, shorter lead times are vital to remain competitive.
6. Sustainability and ethical business practices: Going green is big business today, and effective sourcing can be used to prioritize suppliers who demonstrate sustainable practices, contributing to corporate social responsibility and environmental goals. Compliance problems are also reduced by working with reputable suppliers who understand the importance of adhering to regulatory requirements and ethical standards. In addition to the inherent ethical benefits of sustainability, these efforts can also be used to prop up a company’s marketing efforts, as seen repeatedly in the modern business space.
7. Fostering innovation and maintaining a competitive advantage: Strong supplier relationships can foster innovation through collaboration, leading to new products or improved processes. Often a supplier or vendor has valuable insights into market trends or new technologies that a business may not be aware of. Suppliers can also be exploited (in a collaborative way) for innovative ideas or new ways of thinking or seeing a particular problem. Aligning objectives with suppliers can create a win-win scenario, improving performance for both parties.
8. Better inventory management: Effective sourcing allows for better planning and inventory control due to a more reliable and steady supply stream. This reduces excess stock and minimizes carrying costs. A predictable, reliable supply flow also enables Just-In-Time (JIT) inventory capability and/or manufacturing, since this relies on materials arriving exactly when needed.
9. Improved customer satisfaction: Consistent sourcing leads to reliable product availability, which has a direct impact on customer satisfaction and loyalty. Improved product quality (as noted above), helps meet and exceed customer expectations and enhances any brand’s reputation.

Best practices in sourcing

Now that we’ve uncovered the benefits of improved sourcing, let's go over the specific best practices that can help a company achieve those improvements.

• Evaluate and select suppliers strategically: Establish clear criteria for supplier selection based on quality, cost, reliability, responsiveness, and innovation. Consider each supplier’s sustainability practices, financial stability, technological capabilities, valuable local relationships, and any other criteria your organization prioritizes.
• Diversify your base of suppliers: Engage with a wide range of suppliers to mitigate risk. This approach reduces dependency on a single source and enhances flexibility in responding to market changes. Ideally, you should consider maintaining secondary or tertiary sources of key services/materials/goods in different locations, especially when sourcing globally. In some cases this may not be possible, since some materials are geographically unique. However, where it is feasible, the additional initial cost and time invested to maintain “backup” sources and relationships can be well worth it during supply chain disruptions.
• Build strong relationships with key suppliers: As noted above, fostering collaborative relationships with suppliers can lead to improved communication, reliable supply flow, supplier satisfaction, shared risk management, and innovation. Regular interactions and performance reviews can enhance these relationships. When expectations are clear and goals are well-defined, suppliers can work hard to improve and meet KPIs, further improving the relationship on both ends.
• Prioritize long-term partnerships where appropriate: This may not always be possible, depending on the industry, the materials/services in question, and other factors. However, establishing long-term agreements or partnerships with reliable suppliers not only helps secure favorable pricing but also encourages suppliers to invest in their capabilities to more effectively meet your needs. It also creates a situation of mutual trust where innovation can be shared and discussed, improving both the source and the parent organization.
• Leverage technology: Using digital tools, advanced sourcing software, and data analytics, businesses can greatly enhance supplier evaluation, selection, communication, collaboration, innovation, and risk management. Technologies like eProcurement platforms (where appropriate) and AI-enhanced software solutions can facilitate transparency and efficiency. Data analytics can provide valuable insights into supplier performance and market trends. Real-time data can inform decision-making and help identify potential sourcing challenges early.
• Manage risk: Accurate supply chain mapping can identify critical suppliers and uncover potential vulnerabilities, allowing for proactive risk management in advance of problems. Companies should develop contingency plans for multiple types of supply chain disruptions and critical sourcing scenarios. As noted above, this includes identifying alternative suppliers (potentially contracting with them on a limited or preliminary basis) and maintaining safety stock to help mitigate supply disruptions.
• Consider prioritizing sustainability and ethical sourcing: Prioritizing suppliers that adhere to sustainable and ethical practices, relevant regulations, and industry standards not only enhances brand reputation but also meets the growing consumer demand for environmentally friendly, ethically sourced products. It also helps mitigate legal or operational disruptions relating to suppliers acting poorly.

Common challenges in sourcing and some solutions

Following the best practices above can enhance sourcing efficiency, reduce costs, improve relationships, and support growth. However, everyone in the supply chain needs to be prepared for the volatility of today’s global markets and develop scenarios to help mitigate disruptions and operational problems. Let’s look at some of the common challenges faced during the modern sourcing process, and go over some potential solutions to each.

• Globalization and supply chain complexity: As companies increasingly source materials and components from around the globe, it also grows more difficult and complex to manage such a diversified supply chain. Local, national, and international regulations, cultural differences, and even weather events and geopolitical factors can disrupt sourcing operations, with profound impacts up the supply chain.

To help mitigate this risk, SCM heads and sourcing experts must develop robust risk management strategies that include regular assessment of geopolitical risks, regulatory changes, material shortages, and other factors that impact sourcing in supplier countries or locales. As noted earlier, maintaining alternative sources and suppliers, ideally from significantly different locations and possibly utilizing varied logistics avenues, can help soften the blow of localized or even global disruptions.

• Market volatility: Fluctuations in market demand and available supply are often unpredictable and can have dramatic impacts on sourcing decisions. Economic downturns, natural disasters, and pandemics can create significant disruptions with long-reaching impacts.

There’s no way to fully predict market volatility. However, similar to the above, flexible sourcing strategies help allow for quick adjustments in supplier relationships and inventory levels in unstable times. If it fits your business model and organizational strategy, consider implementing just-in-time processes balanced with appropriate levels of safety stock.

• Quality control issues: Ensuring consistent quality from suppliers can be a major challenge, particularly when sourcing from multiple vendors across different countries or even continents. Quality issues can lead to production delays, spikes in operational costs, and customer dissatisfaction.

To help hedge against QC issues, establish strict quality control measures, clearly communicate the necessary requirements to all suppliers and vendors, and follow up with regular audits of all parties and processes involved. If QC is a recurring issue, collaborate with suppliers to improve quality standards and processes, and/or consider hiring an outside consultant who may be able to see the problem with fresher eyes.

• Technological disparity: Particularly in global supply chains utilizing procurement in less-developed regions, not all suppliers may have access to the latest technology. This may create issues in communication, data sharing, and process efficiency. Supplier evaluation or auditing may be difficult. National regulatory websites or resources may be incompatible or difficult to work with.

These issues can be at least partially mitigated by ensuring that key suppliers are given training and support, including providing software or systems that facilitate data-sharing, training, auditing, and communication. Where appropriate and in accordance with your business’s security protocols, consider integrating primary, trusted suppliers into your technological ecosystem for improved collaboration.

• Cost pressures or economic imbalance: As competition intensifies, companies inevitably face significant pressure to minimize costs while maintaining quality. Since acquisition, procurement, and sourcing are a fundamental cost factor and in an increasingly global market, problems can arise when business leadership teams and stockholders demand cost cuts. Often these are passed down to the sourcing-level relationships and can lead to challenges in negotiating or re-negotiating favorable terms with suppliers. Where suppliers have been loyal and collaborative with a business organization for years, it can feel like a betrayal when they are asked to cut their prices or source additional materials when they feel they are already doing all they can.

It’s most useful to maintain transparent communication with suppliers about cost pressures, including sharing any disclosable information about the economic state of the business and relevant market conditions in order to help suppliers understand the situation. Together, explore value engineering and potential out-of-the-box solutions that may reduce costs without compromising quality. If suppliers feel more involved and informed, they will be more likely to remain loyal and keep QC efforts strong in the face of financial pressure.

In an increasingly complex and dynamic business environment, companies that prioritize effective, technologically and locationally diverse sourcing practices will be better positioned to navigate challenges, seize opportunities, and drive sustainable, ethical growth. Ultimately, an effective sourcing strategy not only enhances supply chain efficiency but contributes to customer satisfaction and long-term company success.

‍